My Current Top 172 (in no particular order)

1. Matt Dallas
2. Leonard Nimoy
3. Johnny Galecki
4. Mike Myers
5. Matthew Gray Gubler
6. Uncle Larry
7. Ben Johnson
8. Ben Graupner
9. Jerad Anderson
10. Monroe Jackson Rathbone
11. Johnny Depp
12. Lee Pace
13. Steve Carell
14. Heath Ledger
15. Michael Jackson
16. Adam Lambert
17. Taylor Hicks
18. Brad Pitt
19. Helena Bonham-Carter
20. Tobey Maguire
21. Chuck Norris
22. Neil Patrick Harris
23. Anne Hathaway
24. Gene Wilder
25. Jim Parsons
26. Zachary Quinto
27. John Lennon
28. Justin Timberlake
29. Hugh Jackman
30. Peter Facinelli
31. Robert Downey Jr.
32. Tim Burton
33. Morgan Freeman
34. Taylor Lautner
35. Jack Black
36. Leonardo DiCaprio
37. Nathan Kress
38. Bela Lugosi
39. Ricky Gervais
40. James Roday
41. Dule Hill
42. Elijah Wood
43. Sandra Bullock
44. Andy Samberg
45. Jerry Trainor
46. Ashley Greene
47. Jimmy Stewart
48. Jesse Tyler Ferguson
49. Cory Monteith
50. Matthew Morrison
51. Chris Colfer
52. Adam Young
53. Wesley Eure
54. George Lopez
55. Jimmy Fallon
56. Nick Cage
57. George Clooney
58. Tom Hanks
59. Harrison Ford
60. Matthew Perry
61. Ben Stiller
62. Jessica Alba
63. Josh Groban
64. Masi Oka
65. Brendan Fraser
66. Jim Carrey
67. Paul McCartney
68. George Harrison
69. Ringo Star
70. Chris Pine
71. Will Ferrell
72. Zachary Levi
73. Hamish Linklater
74. Vince Vaughn
75. Justin Long
76. David Hasselhoff
77. Rainn Wilson
78. John Krasinski
79. Simon Cowell
80. America Ferrara
81. Robert Pattinson
82. Charles Shaughnessy
83. Gene Simmons
84. Brad Garrett
85. J.J. Abrams
86. Joel McHale
87. John C. Reilly
88. Tony Shalhoub
89. Christian Bale
90. Shia LaBeouf
91. Eric Mabius
92. Mark Indelicato
93. Michael Urie
94. Jake Gyllenhaal
95. Tina Fey
96. Robin Williams
97. Dwayne Johnson
98. Seth MacFarlane
99. Tom Kenny
100. Seth Green
101. Jerry Seinfeld
102. Paula Poundstone
103. Criss Angel
104. Adam Sandler
105. David Hyde Pierce
106. Patrick Stewart
107. Jon Foster
108. Taylor Swift
109. Jim Creeggan
110. Kevin Hearn
111. Ed Robertson
112. Tyler Stewart
113. Pete Wentz
114. Billie Joe Armstrong
115. Mike Dirnt
116. Tré Cool
117. Jude Law
118. Gwyneth Paltrow
119. Colin Farrell
120. Russell Tovey
121. Lenora Crichlow
122. Aidan Turner
123. Jason Watkins
124. John Cho
125. Gene Roddenberry
126. DeForest Kelley
127. Drake Bell
128. Josh Peck
129. Brent Spiner
130. Bill Murray
131. Bill Nye
132. Chevy Chase
133. David Duchovny
134. Jennie Garth
135. Amanda Bynes
136. Johnny Cash
137. Jim Gaffigan
138. Chris Lowell
139. Brian McElhaney
140. Nick Kocher
141. Hugh Laurie
142. Ellen DeGeneres
143. Will Smith
144. James Franco
145. Simon Helberg
146. Kaley Cuoco
147. Kunal Nayyar
148. Zoë Saldana
149. Cameron Diaz
150. Jane Lynch
151. Jeff Dunham
152. John Goodman
153. Anton Yelchin
154. Eric Bana
155. Bruce Greenwood
156. Karl Urban
157. Simon Pegg
158. Winona Ryder
159. Nichelle Nichols
160. Greg Grunberg
161. Anna Friel
162. Danny McBride
163. Zooey Deschanel
164. Halle Berry
165. Rachel Weisz
166. Brendan Fraser
167. Zach Braff
168. Donald Faison
169. John C. McGinley
170. Michael Cera
171. Jonah Hill
172. Elvis Presley